Put down that industrial-sized bag of Hershey bars, and dig into these Halloween Paleo treats instead!
On the surface, Halloween looks like a challenging Holiday for health-conscious Paleo dieters. However, there’s no reason to sacrifice clean eating on the day of candy worship.
From Milky Way, to Twix, to Butterfingers, we’ve compiled Paleo versions of all your favorite treats. If you’re a gummy candy lover, we’ve got simple, fruity, and even healthy gummies listed here. Additionally, if you’re in the mood for something unique, you should try some sunbutter fudge or truffle-like carrot cake balls.
Whichever way you decide, we’ve got all the Paleo treats you’ll ever want this Halloween!
Milky Way Bars
Creamy, gooey chocolate marshmallows (made with gut-healing gelatin) are covered in a coconut cream caramel and antioxidant-rich dark chocolate. So good, the Mars version can’t compete.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Milky Way Bars
Paleo Twix Bar
Yes, every part of this miraculous treat is Paleo. That means you can enjoy the crisp shortbread, gooey caramel and chocolate coating of your favorite candy free from guilt.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Paleo Twix Bar
Fed and Fit made these Paleo-friendly Almond Joys specifically to fulfill a craving for Halloween candy. Reap the benefits of her brilliant thinking.
Recipe: Fed and Fit | Almond Joys
Caramel Cheesecake Bites
A coconut cream and cashew based “cheese” cake gets doused in the easiest caramel sauce you’ll ever make.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Caramel Cheesecake Bites
Chewy Rice-less Krispies
If you didn’t think it was possible, think again my friend. These treats contain yummy almonds, macadamia nuts, honey and almond butter — ensuring ultimate candied crunch in every bite.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Chewy Rice-less Krispies
Homemade Kit Kat Bars Recipe
Give yourself a break with these all-natural Kit Kat bars. It locks an all natural chocolate crunch without using any refined sugars.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Homemade Kit Kat Bars Recipe
Nut Butter Cups
Your house is bound to be the coolest on the block when you hand these chocolate nut-butter beauties out this Halloween.
Recipe: Clean Eating with a Dirty Mind | Nut Butter Cups
Chocolate Pecan Truffles
These decadent, cocoa-rich truffles are rolled in crunchy ground Pecans—a perfect adult Halloween treat.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Chocolate Pecan Truffles
Fool your friends (and picky kids) with Paleo Rolos—with the proper mold, they won’t be able to tell the difference.
Recipe: Against All Grain | Rolos
DIY Paleo Thin Mints
Peppermint extract, coconut manna, and chocolate are perfect mini mint-candy treats.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | DIY Paleo Thin Mints
Paleo Coconut Macaroons
Crunchy. Sweet. Coconut. 100% Paleo. What else is there to say?
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Paleo Coconut Macaroons
Balsamic Blueberry Gummies
For a more refined approach to gummy candies, try this delicious combo antioxidant-rich blueberries and gut-nourishing gelatin. They’re as good as candy can be for you.
Recipe: The Primalist | Balsamic Blueberry Gummies
Easy, Paleo Butterfingers Recipe
Craving the sticky, crunchy, and flaky texture of butterfingers? Give this almond butter-based version a try.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Easy, Paleo Butterfingers Butterfingers
Coconut Mounds Bark
This recipe is a cross between fudge, chocolate bark, and a candy bar.
Recipe: Living Healthy with Chocolate | Coconut Mounds Bark
Sour Watermelon Gummies
Missing Sour Patch kids? Try these sour watermelon gummies. Meatified even provides you a handy guide to which fruits you can and can’t sub into the gummy recipe.
Recipe: Meatified | Sour Watermelon Gummies
Remarkably, these peppermint patties take only six ingredients to replicate that cool, creamy, coconut filling flavor. With a snap of a dark chocolate layer, it’s even better.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Peppermint Patties
Perfect fluffy Paleo marshmallows get dipped in dark chocolate. Yes, you should make Paleo s’mores.
Recipe: Our Paleo Life | Chocolate-Dipped Marshmallows
Carrot Cake Bites
For something a little different, try these super simple truffle-esque carrot cake bites. Just throw dates, carrots, coconut, cinnamon and nutmeg in a food processor, then roll the bites in extra coconut for bite-sized Paleo treats.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Carrot Cake Bites
Fluffernutter Chocolate Cups
Our Paleo Life takes their marshmallow recipe to the next level! They amp it up by sandwiching marshmallows and almond butter in a dark chocolate cup.
Recipe: Our Paleo Life | Fluffernutter Chocolate Cups
Peppermint Chocolate Truffles
Who says you can’t have chocolate peppermint candy this Halloween? Indulge in all that minty-chocolate goodness on any day of the year.
Recipe: Our Paleo Life | Peppermint Chocolate Truffles
Dark Chocolate Bacon Bark
Rich dark chocolate melds with maple syrup and crunchy pieces of pastured bacon. Top with Himalayan pink salt if you’re feeling fancy.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Dark Chocolate Bacon Bark
Who needs a Hershey’s chocolate bar when you could be nibbling on these Paleo treats instead?
Recipe: nzgirl | Chocolate Bars
Easy Apple Pops
These Candied Apple Pops are drenched in chocolate, drizzled with caramel sauce, and topped with nuts. They’re the perfect fall treat!
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Easy Apple Pops
Full of healthy fats, this sunbutter fudge takes only five minutes of prep and some patience for the freezer.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Sunbutter Fudge
Raw Walnut Fudge
These nutty Paleo treats are full of healthy fats and need only an hour in the freezer.
Recipe: Clean Eating with a Dirty Mind | Raw Walnut Fudge
Gut-Healing Kombucha Gummies
Channel your love of gut-nourishing Kombucha into these gummy candies. Bonus points if they’re made in a Halloween-themed mold.
Recipe: PaleoHacks | Gut-Healing Kombucha Gummies
(You’ll Also Love: 37 Keto Desserts: Low in Carbs + Zero Refined Sugars)